Back by popular demand, Homemade Oreos! Last year the treats we passed out to our neighbors were a variety of cookies. Everyone looked at the plate and said, "Ah, man I thought you would do the homemade oreos again."
Well, after that reaction, we decided to go back to the Homemade Oreos this year. And the responses have been all-positives.
Lesson here: If it's good, and a crowd-pleaser, don't change it.